Golf course challengers ordered to pay $150k in state costs
The Federal Court on 19 Nov ordered two litigants to pay $150k of the SA government's legal costs after their North Adelaide golf course challenge failed.
Last verified · How we report · Report a correction

- Source Briefing
- Read original source · ABC News
The Federal Court on Thursday 19 November ordered two litigants who failed in their bid to halt the North Adelaide Golf Course upgrade to cover $150,000 of the South Australian government’s legal costs, according to ABC News.
Judge Natalie Charlesworth made the order against public servant Edwin Kemp Attrill and Kaurna woman Janette Milera. Before the hearing they had rejected a government settlement offer of the same $150,000.
The news that moved today. Free email. Every weekday morning.
Why it matters
The two had asked the court to halt the upgrade of the North Adelaide parklands course, which involves felling 585 trees. They argued the redevelopment breached federal conservation law.
In October Justice Charlesworth found against them, saying she was unconvinced the plans would have a “significant impact on species”.
Minister Nick Champion (Labor) said the government sought costs to protect taxpayers’ interests, ABC News reported.
Our earlier coverage of tree removal in the Adelaide parklands is in the MotoGP circuit first-trees story.
The numbers
- $150,000: the costs order against Mr Kemp Attrill and Ms Milera.
- $450,000 to $550,000: the government’s total legal bill, a range Premier Peter Malinauskas has previously given, per ABC News.
- 585: trees to be felled for the upgrade.
- $132,000: raised by Mr Kemp Attrill on GoFundMe to fund his court case.
ABC News reports the pair have previously said that a costs claim by the government would probably bankrupt them. The litigants had lawyers working pro bono, meaning their legal team was not paid. The order now sits at the same figure the government had earlier offered as a settlement. That means the two litigants end up facing the same bill they could have accepted before the hearing, and the order covers only part of the government’s overall legal costs, which Premier Peter Malinauskas has put in a far higher range.
On Wednesday, Mr Kemp Attrill’s barrister told the court the case served the public interest and that special circumstances should count when costs were set. The government’s lawyer rejected that, though she signalled no objection to a $150,000 costs order.
Justice Charlesworth did not accept several arguments from the litigants’ lawyers against an adverse costs order, among them a claim that it could deter similar cases being brought.
What’s next
ABC News did not report whether the two will appeal the costs order or how they plan to pay it. The report also did not say when the government expects to begin the tree removal.
Quick answers
What are the key numbers in this story?
costs order: $150k; trees: 585; GoFundMe raised: $132k.
Where does this information come from?
This story cites ABC News. Every source is linked on the page.
Sources
Also reported by
Filed by the AusDev Adelaide Desk. How we report.
Next story · AdelaideFDC and BWP finish $25m Noarlunga Heights Super CentreA $25m redevelopment has turned the former Bunnings Warehouse at Noarlunga Heights, Adelaide, into a large-format retail centre, Inside Construction reports.