Thu, 19 Nov 2026

Builder must pay $269,982 for Latham home defects after appeal

The ACT Court of Appeal kept the damages order but told the owners to credit part of a $200,000 certifier settlement, with the first $17,100.94 left out of the credit.

Last verified · How we report · Report a correction

Illustration for: Builder must pay $269,982 for Latham home defects after appeal
$269,982.66damages ordered
$200,000certifier settlement
$95,746.57site cut

The ACT Court of Appeal has upheld a $269,982.66 damages order against M Johnson Building Pty Ltd over a house in Latham, Canberra, but sent part of a certifier’s settlement back into the sums, according to a Times of India report on 17 November 2026. The report cites the court’s judgment, and we have not seen the judgment itself.

The report says the builder lost on the main point at the ACT Supreme Court, which found it breached its building contract. The two owners had alleged the house was not built to the approved plans and building standards, and that other work was defective.

The news that moved today. Free email. Every weekday morning.

Why it matters

The appeal was about double recovery. Times of India reports the owners also sued the certifier, Capital Certifiers Pty Ltd, and settled shortly before trial, with the certifier paying $200,000 including costs on 17 May 2023.

The builder wanted that money deducted from what it owes. The Court of Appeal accepted that the owners cannot be paid twice for one loss, the report says, but refused to subtract the full $200,000. Some losses were shared by both parties, while others sat only with the builder.

As reported, the owners must credit any part of the settlement above $17,100.94, plus one-third of their solicitor-client costs up to 20 April 2023. For builders and certifiers in the Territory, it shows how a settlement with one party can flow into a claim against another. ACT building rules are also being changed separately, as covered in our story on the building bill.

The numbers

  • Total damages were assessed at $287,084 at the Supreme Court, which ordered the builder to pay $269,982.66, per the report.
  • The gap reflects an agreed split of 85% builder and 15% certifier for shared losses, with some items falling wholly to the builder because they were outside the certifier’s supervision.
  • The $95,746.57 site cut cost was not in dispute on appeal. The plans called for 88 cubic metres of land to be removed, and the builder accepted the excavation was not done as specified.
  • Engineers called the existing excavation unsafe because of its height and near-vertical face. Repairs included reshaping the slope and building retaining walls.
  • The builder said the contract left the site cut with the owners, pointing to a $3,000 siteworks allowance or a landscaping exclusion. The primary judge rejected the landscaping argument.

What’s next

The Court of Appeal dismissed the claim that the owners carried the site cut cost, noting it was not put forward at trial and that the contract set no provisional sums. The parties have 14 days to file submissions on the costs of the appeal and the trial.

The builder has not responded in the report, and the findings described are the court’s, as reported, not allegations by us. Times of India says it has not independently verified the defects, breaches or costs, and that the findings come from court records.

Quick answers

What is the latest on Latham house defects case?

The ACT Court of Appeal kept the damages order but told the owners to credit part of a $200,000 certifier settlement, with the first $17,100.94 left out of the credit.

Which companies are named in the Latham house defects case story?

M Johnson Building is named in this story, which cites Times of India, 17 Nov 2026.

What are the key numbers for Latham house defects case?

damages ordered: $269,982.66; certifier settlement: $200,000; site cut: $95,746.57.

Sources

How we report →

Filed by the AusDev Canberra Desk. How we report.

Next story · CanberraACT approved 822 homes in June quarter, finished 617ABS tables put ACT approvals at 822 dwellings and completions at 617 for the June 2026 quarter, with 867 approvals in the September quarter.
Newsletter

Get the Canberra Daily Index

One free briefing every weekday morning.